Homebuilder Sentiment Plummets to 2024 Nadir of 34

Builders Are Losing Confidence Fast

America's homebuilders just hit their lowest point of the year.

The index works like a thermometer for builder confidence - any reading under 50 means more builders think conditions are bad than good. At 34, that gap is wide.

This is not a one-month blip. The index has now stayed below 40 for 15 months in a row, the longest such run since 2012. Builders are stuck in a rut, and they are starting to try harder to get buyers in the door.

To understand the index's significance, it is compiled from a monthly survey of NAHB members who rate present sales, expectations for the next six months, and traffic of prospective buyers. A sustained reading below 50 historically signals a contracting market, and the current 34 level suggests builders are deeply pessimistic about near-term prospects for both sales and construction activity. This prolonged weakness has already led to cutbacks in new projects, which in turn reduces housing supply and keeps upward pressure on prices.

Get the market news that matters in a five-minute read with Market Briefs, our free daily newsletter

The Same Old Problems, Plus a Few New Ones

The reasons for the slump are not hard to find. Mortgage rates are still high. Land is expensive.

Materials keep getting more expensive. And there is a persistent shortage of skilled labor.

NAHB Chief Economist Robert Dietz put it plainly: "Affordability remains the home building industry's primary challenge, as elevated mortgage rates, costly land, rising material prices, and persistent skilled labor shortages continue to affect the market."

On top of those familiar headaches, builders are dealing with uncertainty over tariffs and a weakening job market. According to Pantheon Macroenomics' senior US economist, Oliver Allen, demand for new homes had already been weak prior to the additional strain from Middle East tensions. He said the recent climb in mortgage rates "has added to homebuilders' woes."

The prolonged weakness in builder confidence has significant implications for the broader economy. With housing starts expected to decline, the supply of new homes will remain constrained, further pressuring home prices and affordability.

The pain is hitting some regions harder than others. In the Northeast, builder confidence fell by nine points to 41, marking the largest monthly decline since last November.

Meanwhile, the market for existing homes is showing the same weakness. Pending home sales - a measure of signed contracts for previously owned homes - fell 5.4% in June, landing at an index of 72.5. Economists had predicted a drop of just 0.5%.

Market watchers will get another piece of the puzzle this Friday when the federal government releases its update on June housing starts. That data will show whether builders are actually breaking ground on fewer projects or just feeling pessimistic.

Join Market Briefs, our free daily newsletter, for a quick daily rundown of the markets