Cheaper loans were supposed to make homes easier to afford.
Rates did fall in early 2026. The cost of owning a home went up anyway.
The reason is a line the Fed cannot touch. It is your home insurance bill.
A house payment has four parts. There is the loan, the interest, the taxes, and the insurance.
The Fed only moves the first two. The part that keeps rising is insurance.
And it has risen fast. Home insurance rose 46.8% from 2020 to 2025, LendingTree found.
No state got a break. Bills rose another 6% in 2025 alone.
The typical home now costs about $2,395 a year to cover. Five years ago, the bill was far smaller.
The spread between states is huge. Oklahoma leads near $5,298 a year, while Hawaii sits close to $801.
We turn the bills hiding in your budget into plain English in Market Briefs, the free daily read that comes with an investing masterclass when you join.
Two things drive it. First, more big storms.
The country saw about 23 billion-dollar disasters a year from 2020 to 2024. Before that, it saw about 15 a year.
Second, repairs cost more. Lumber alone jumped over 300% across 2020 and 2021.
So every claim costs more to pay. Insurers pass that cost on to you.
One study put the jump even higher. The Consumer Federation of America found bills rose about 24% in three years.
That is roughly twice the pace of inflation. Some states fared far worse, with Colorado costs more than doubling.
Higher bills are changing how people shop. About 1 in 10 owners raised their deductible just to cut the cost.
Others dropped coverage for good. More than 12 million homes went uninsured in 2024.
Builders feel it too. Builder confidence just hit its longest slump since 2012.
Buyers are stretched. Yet they keep showing up whenever rates dip.
The map of pain is lopsided. A few states drove most of the rise.
Colorado costs more than doubled from 2020 to 2025. Iowa and Minnesota were not far behind.
Why those states? They sit in the path of tornadoes and hail.
That makes claims more common. It also makes them costlier to pay.
The worst single year was 2024. Bills rose 12.7% that year alone.
Owners are reacting in real time. About 1 in 5 plan to switch insurers within a year.
Some are giving up entirely. Roughly 14% of homes now carry no coverage at all.
That last number is the warning sign. When people drop coverage, one bad storm can wipe them out.
The bill is no longer a small line. It now shapes whether a home is worth buying.
LendingTree expects the rises to slow. It does not expect them to stop.
The mortgage is getting cheaper. The house is not.
If you want this read before your coffee gets cold, join 350,000+ investors reading Market Briefs each morning, plus a 45-minute investing course on the way in.
How To Use ChatGPT & Claude To Research Stocks Like A Pro
Save my seat →You’re in!
Make sure to check your inbox for the first email.
Before you go
We’re hosting our first ever livestream on how investors can use ChatGPT & Claude to invest like a pro. It’s on 11/17 and is hosted by our CEO Jaspreet Singh.
Click here to join →
