Shopify, the Ottawa-based e-commerce software firm, had been having a rough stretch. Heading into Tuesday's close, the stock was down 23% year to date.
The Nasdaq, by comparison, had risen 14% over the same stretch. Much of the anxiety came down to one question: would AI upend Shopify's business?
The company answered with its latest forecast. The company's forecast calls for third-quarter sales to climb in the low 30s, better than the 27 percent increase analysts projected. That may not look like a huge difference, but investors took it as a signal that AI is not the threat they feared.
At one point, shares were up 25%, the largest single-day gain since November 2024.
By 11:03 a.m. EDT, the stock was up 18% from the previous close.
Later market data showed Shopify at 202.77. That was up 16.01% on the day.
It wasn't just the forecast that looked good. Second-quarter revenue beat estimates.
Both its subscription business and its merchant business came in stronger than expected.
Operating costs rose 21%.
That was just under what analysts had predicted. CFO Jeff Hoffmeister said the increase mostly reflected careful headcount management.
That cost detail matters. Before the quarter, Bloomberg Intelligence analyst Anurag Rana had worried that higher AI costs would squeeze Shopify's profit margin.
Get the free Always Be Buying eBook and learn the simple system for building wealth on any income
After seeing the actual numbers, he wrote that the results show a low risk of AI disruption and that AI tools likely helped the company take market share from rivals faster.
That would extend a strong streak. If Shopify hits its forecast, it will be the sixth straight quarter with revenue growth over 30%.
That means the company is growing faster than Wall Street expected, and it is doing that while spending more on AI.
Part of the fear came from Shopify's own earnings call. In May, the company said AI generates over half of its code.
That is proof Shopify is using AI heavily, but it also fed the worry that AI could disrupt Shopify more than help it.
Then in July, Rothschild & Co. Redburn analysts moved their recommendation on Shopify to neutral, saying Meta Platforms Inc.'s move to offer AI tools for small businesses could weaken Shopify's competitive position.
On the day Shopify jumped, Meta traded at 585.15.
Meta was up just 0.47%. That contrast told a simple story: investors were not treating the news as bad for Meta or as a sign that Meta was beating Shopify.
The broader question remains whether AI can make it easier for rivals to chip away at Shopify's role as the e-commerce platform. The company's forecast did not settle that debate, but the latest numbers gave investors a reason to focus on growth rather than disruption risk.
For your money, this is a reminder that market panic and market reality can move at different speeds.
But the company's numbers show it can use AI and still grow. The result is a more balanced picture than the fear suggested.
No single quarter settles the story. The next step is whether Shopify can keep this up.
A streak like that would not be a fluke, but the company has to prove itself again every few months.
If it does, the AI story becomes a growth story. If the growth slips, the old worries will probably be back.
For your portfolio, the practical question is not whether Shopify is a good company. It is whether a stock's price already reflects the good news and the bad.
With shares having jumped 25% at their peak, the market has made its choice for now. The quarters ahead will decide if that choice was right.
Download the free Always Be Buying eBook and start putting your money to work today