Free NewsletterPro Login

Warning: Undefined variable $stocks in /var/www/briefs.co/htdocs/wp-content/plugins/oxygen/component-framework/components/classes/code-block.class.php(133) : eval()'d code on line 448

Warning: foreach() argument must be of type array|object, null given in /var/www/briefs.co/htdocs/wp-content/plugins/oxygen/component-framework/components/classes/code-block.class.php(133) : eval()'d code on line 448

Warning: Undefined variable $funds in /var/www/briefs.co/htdocs/wp-content/plugins/oxygen/component-framework/components/classes/code-block.class.php(133) : eval()'d code on line 472

Warning: foreach() argument must be of type array|object, null given in /var/www/briefs.co/htdocs/wp-content/plugins/oxygen/component-framework/components/classes/code-block.class.php(133) : eval()'d code on line 472
/* the link was here */
×
Free investor livestream — Nov 17

How To Use ChatGPT & Claude To Research Stocks Like A Pro

01
The prompt we use to break down any stock
02
How to fact-check what AI tells you
03
How to compare two stocks in minutes

IRS and Treasury put guardrails on using Section 351 to seed ETFs

Published Oct 2, 2026
Share:
Summary:
  • Tax officials issued a revenue ruling and a notice aimed at certain ETF seeding maneuvers that defer capital gains using Section 351.
  • The focus: wealthy investors forming new ETFs via intermediaries, contributing big gains stock baskets, then winding up with different holdings without triggering tax.
  • Regulators want public feedback by October 28, and while tax deferral is still possible, it comes with tighter conditions and timing scrutiny.

What changed and why it matters

Tax authorities rolled out a revenue ruling alongside a broader notice that zero in on ETF setups they find problematic. In the scenario highlighted by the ruling, an investor contributed a portfolio to a brand new ETF, which then distributed those same securities soon after, leaving the investor with a "materially different" mix and no recognition of built-in gains on the original holdings.

The point, regulators say, is often to sidestep capital gains bills. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent said on X earlier this week that the move "makes clear Treasury is serious about cracking down on transactions designed to dodge taxes or exploit our federal tax code." On a related IRS ruling covering Section 351 ETF conversions meant to avoid tax, he added, "Our message on these conversions is clear: they don't work under existing law."

A Bloomberg review last July found roughly $22 billion in ETFs had been launched for this purpose, potentially deferring up to $6.5 billion in gains, with activity ramping notably since 2024. In July, IRS and Treasury officials sat down with the Wall Street Tax Association to review deals attracting agency scrutiny, among them disputed Section 351 exchanges. The new notice takes up a wide swath of the tactics discussed.

How Section 351 works and who typically uses it

Section 351 generally allows someone to contribute assets to a corporation and receive its shares without immediately recognizing a gain, as long as the structure clears certain hurdles. As summarized by Kitces.com, no single position can make up more than 25% of the portfolio, and the top five names together cannot exceed 50% of the portfolio's value. That framework remains broadly accepted.

"The IRS and Treasury are focused on tax strategies that they consider abusive practices," said Jeffrey Colon, a Fordham Law professor who specializes in tax. In the case that drew the ruling, "This is really about getting diversification without paying tax," Brian Gray, a tax partner at Gursey Schneider, said.

This is mostly the domain of the very affluent. John Pantekidis of TwinFocus in Boston, who holds the dual roles of managing partner and general counsel, estimates that setting up an ETF typically costs $200,000 to $300,000. Some providers suggest having at least $25 million of appreciated stock to make the math work, but Pantekidis sets the bar higher, saying it is not sensible for anyone contributing less than $100 million in stock.

There are legitimate uses. Joshua Norman, who serves as a principal in Cerity Partners' Bardstown, Kentucky office, noted situations like a donor wanting to gift ETF shares to someone who does not want individual stock positions. He also said moving separately managed accounts into an ETF wrapper can reduce ongoing tax friction for wealthy clients and improve after tax outcomes.

The notice itself carved out room for standard seeding: "This notice does not address, and expresses no view regarding, transactions in which a Section 351 transaction is used to seed a newly established ETF with assets that are consistent with the ETF's investment thesis and that are intended and expected to be retained by the ETF absent a substantial change in circumstances." And some see the door still open. "Non consensus view: Regulators opened the door this week for well designed 351s to hit the mainstream," wrote Mel Faber, founder of Cambria Funds.

Markets move every day, and most of it never reaches you in time. Get the free Market Briefs daily newsletter and stay ahead of it.

Timing tests, gray areas, and what comes next

Regulators are tightening the conditions for transactions to qualify as tax deferred under this pathway. Timing is a big one. The notice indicates that when appreciated securities are contributed and actions occur "shortly after," the transactions raise red flags, yet it leaves the exact timeframe undefined. That ambiguity will linger until more detail arrives, Norman said.

Others expect facts and circumstances to drive the analysis for now. For his part, tax analyst Brent Sullivan, who operates the Tax Alpha Insider blog, wrote, "Regarding Treasury's Rev. Rul. on §351 for seeding ETFs, I'm looking at 3 things as evidence of aggressive planning... 1) evidence of a plan 2) quick redemption following seed 3) a very different portfolio from the contribution. This leaves a lot of gray area and I think we'll see many 'facts and circumstances' analyses in the coming months/years." Ed Zollars, a tax partner at Thomas, Zollars & Lynch, cautioned that "Tax practitioners must understand these highlighted strategies to advise clients on emerging audit exposures."

Officials are taking feedback and asked for comments by October 28.

Other strategies in the crosshairs, and the bottom line for your money

The notice also highlights other targets, such as shifting assets into partnerships as part of Section 351 conversions, and ETFs employing "box spread" option setups that can defer capital gains. Congress could weigh in too, potentially narrowing how ETFs benefit from distributing appreciated securities, said Colon.

Back in July, Bessent wrote on X, "Tax rules should reward investment, not abusive financial engineering," adding that regulators "will not turn a blind eye to abusive Wall Street tax dodges or tolerate products designed to exploit our federal tax code. If a tax pitch sounds too good to be true, then it probably is and investors should think twice." He pointed back to that warning in this week's post.

Do not expect regulators to dismantle the core ETF plumbing. "It's a multi-trillion-dollar industry," Pantekidis said, referring to the everyday create and redeem process that big ETFs rely on. But he expects more guardrails for smaller funds that form units and quickly diversify portfolios to harvest tax benefits.

If you are sitting on a concentrated, highly appreciated stock position, advisors are still using well worn alternatives. Gray pointed to exchange funds, private vehicles often set up as limited partnerships that pool concentrated positions into a diversified basket while deferring gains, with a typical seven year wait before redemption. He also mentioned charitable remainder trusts as another way to manage capital gains and losses.

In plain English: the tax playbook around bespoke ETF seeding is tightening, the timing rules are getting sharper, and high earners should assume more case by case review until clearer lines are drawn. That does not kill ETFs, but it does change the calculus on some of the flashier tax maneuvers.

The money story behind the headlines is usually the part that matters. Join Market Briefs free and get it every morning.

Disclosure

Recent News

1 2 3 … 131

Get Market Briefs delivered to your inbox every morning for free!

No fluff. No noise. No politics. Just finance news you can read in 5 minutes.

Blogs

November 17, 2026
Is the Stock Market Going to Crash? Why Nvidia and the Fed Have Investors on Edge
  • Tech stocks are selling off because investors don't know who will lead Nvidia, the company that has been funding the AI industry and selling it chips.
  • Inflation has the Federal Reserve planning to raise interest rates, with a hike expected in December, and that puts pressure on homebuyers, private equity and the $40 trillion national debt.
  • Briefs Finance CEO Jaspreet Singh says nobody has a crystal ball, so his rules are to buy when markets are low, hold long term and invest only what you're willing to lose.
Read More
November 16, 2026
The $40 Trillion National Debt: Trump's 4-Part Plan to Make It Feel Smaller
  • The national debt is above $40 trillion, and the Federal Reserve has gone from sending Washington its profits to losing money.
  • President Trump's four-part plan leans on shorter-term debt, stablecoin companies buying Treasuries, a bigger balance sheet and government stakes in private companies.
  • The goal is to outgrow the debt, not pay it off, so Jaspreet Singh points investors to the seven industries where Washington wants growth.
Read More
November 16, 2026
The Fed Is Talking About a Jumbo Interest Rate Hike. It Has No Easy Way Out
  • The Fed makes its next rate decision on December 9 and is now talking about jumbo interest rate hikes of 0.5%, though one in December looks unlikely.
  • Washington will pay a record $1.05 trillion in interest this year on $40 trillion of debt, and that debt resets at higher rates as the Fed hikes.
  • Jaspreet Singh's five moves are to pay down variable-rate debt, earn interest on your savings, know which stocks feel the pressure, look at value and hedge.
Read More
November 16, 2026
Buying on Margin Is at a Record High. Here's the Risk for the Stock Market
  • Margin debt, the money investors borrow to buy stocks, is at a record of around 4.6% of GDP, up from 3.9% in 2021.
  • ETF money has more than tripled in five years to 7% of GDP, while corporate buybacks and 401(k) money sit below their earlier peaks.
  • Margin calls and panic selling can make the next downturn deeper, so Jaspreet Singh keeps buying broad market funds and says most investors should skip margin debt.
Read More
November 16, 2026
Housing Prices Are Falling. Buying a House Still Isn't Cheaper
  • Housing prices have fallen for four straight weeks, but mortgage rates around 7.2% keep the monthly payment about where it was in 2023.
  • Talk of a jumbo Fed rate hike and a plan to sell Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac on the stock market could both push mortgage rates higher.
  • Briefs Finance CEO Jaspreet Singh treats a house as a liability: buy within your budget and let your investments build the wealth.
Read More
November 14, 2026
Nvidia News: Jensen Huang Is Out, and the "Bank" Behind American AI Just Lost Its Founder
  • Jensen Huang is out at Nvidia over affairs with multiple people, and the company he founded has been the bank of American AI, with about $30 billion into OpenAI and $10 billion into Anthropic.
  • A hotter-than-expected inflation report has Fed officials talking about a possible 0.5% hike in December, and gold, silver, and bitcoin fell on the news.
  • President Trump said the US may not need a deal with Iran, keeping oil prices and inflation risk high. Jaspreet Singh breaks down what it all means for AI stocks and your portfolio.
Read More
November 14, 2026
Record Highs, a 57-Year Low in Jobless Claims, and a Stock Market Bubble: Inside the Weirdest Market in History
  • Stocks are booming at the fastest pace in years, jobless claims just hit a 57-year low, and most investors still feel like nobody is hiring.
  • The Fed is protecting the dollar over the economy, oil swings on every Iran headline, and a few AI companies are carrying an S&P 500 where four of five stocks sit in a correction.
  • Jaspreet Singh explains why circular financing between Nvidia, OpenAI, Anthropic, and SpaceX rhymes with 2008's house of cards, and how his three investing pillars handle a stock market bubble.
Read More
November 14, 2026
Is a Recession Coming? The Fed Just Made a U-Turn It Has Only Made Twice in 60 Years
  • The Fed has raised rates, cut them, then raised them again only twice in the last 60 years, and both times the economy fell into a recession and stocks crashed.
  • The same stop-and-go cycle is playing out now, with one big difference: US debt is 125% of GDP today versus about 30% in 1980.
  • In the 1970s gold rose roughly 24x, real estate 157%, stocks lagged, and cash lost half its value. Jaspreet Singh lays out five assets to consider before the next flip.
Read More
November 14, 2026
The 2027 Tax Brackets Are Out: How Some Investors Can Earn $135,300 and Pay $0
  • The IRS 2027 tax plan keeps the same seven rates but widens every bracket and lifts the married-filing-jointly standard deduction to $33,200.
  • The 0% long-term capital gains bracket rises to $102,100, so a household living on $135,300 of investment income could owe $0 in federal income tax.
  • C corporations still pay 21%, small businesses keep the 20% QBI deduction, and the 401(k) limit climbs to $25,500 with an $8,500 catch-up for investors over 50.
Read More
November 14, 2026
Rare Earth Stocks: Why China's January 2027 Ban Could Be the Opportunity of the Decade
  • China plans to block rare earth exports to the US on January 10, 2027, and the US produces effectively zero of the 17 metals that go into phones, cars, dishwashers, and missiles.
  • When China cut off Japan in 2010 and squeezed Germany from 2015, some rare earth prices jumped 18x and 15x, and one rare earth company went bankrupt while another soared.
  • Washington is already putting billions into MP Materials, Vulcan, and a stockpile called Project Vault, and Jaspreet Singh walks through how investors can get exposure to rare earth stocks and ETFs.
Read More
1 2 3 … 33
Share via
Copy link