What happened
After roughly three months in the job, Ashlee Gabrysch - who previously worked as an analyst at Fitch Ratings - resigned as Chicago's chief financial officer, becoming the third person to leave the CFO post within a year. "As a CFO who had previously spent years as a rating analyst, I am well-versed in the calculation of a budgetary gap," she said, adding she spent "countless hours emailing and calling" city officials to press the issue. Her resignation note was blunt: "To continue in this role would be to compromise my integrity and professional obligations."
The exit rattled aldermen and fiscal watchdogs just as investors were watching how first term Mayor Brandon Johnson would patch a large deficit while running for reelection. The city council responded Wednesday with a 45 to 5 vote to commission an independent investigation tied to her departure and the disclosure concerns she raised.
The budget questions she raised
Gabrysch disputed how the administration defined the shortfall and objected to one time measures that, in her view, made the fiscal 2027 budget appear more structurally balanced. She also flagged how next year's plan treated about $266 million for past police settlements through payments and borrowing. Rating firms track borrowing for settlements as a credit sensitive factor, she said, and investors need clear disclosure on how much of a budget relies on one time versus recurring items.
Her estimate for the hole ran larger than City Hall's. Johnson initially put the deficit near $882.4 million in early September, then in October released an "adjusted budget gap" of $652.5 million. By her math, once roughly $131.5 million in added costs plus $36.1 million for departmental needs were counted, the shortfall was nearer to $1 billion. According to a finance spokesperson, Oct. 26 testimony from Acting Budget Director Jonathan Ernst referenced that bigger number as the sum "between savings and efficiencies and new revenue" required to balance the plan, adding that the yearly budget proposal serves as a planning tool for legislative discussion rather than a financial statement.
"Transparency in numbers is paramount: to taxpayers, to the city council, to rating agencies and to investors, and the failure to provide that transparency puts the city at risk of federal regulatory action," Gabrysch told Bloomberg News. She warned that, should that occur, ratings could be cut, some investors limited to investment-grade holdings might be forced to sell, borrowing would become more expensive, and access to the market could tighten if "rating agencies or investors ever conclude that the City's financial materials, including budget documents, understate borrowing and overstate structural balance."
When city budgets and financial decisions affect everyday life, sign up for the free Market Briefs newsletter for five-minute daily clarity
Ratings pressure and political response
On Wednesday, S&P Global Ratings placed Chicago on credit watch "with negative implications," applying to its general obligation debt as well as bonds backed by sales taxes. The city's GO rating sits at BBB, two steps above junk. Analysts led by Scott Nees warned a negative move is likely if the enacted fiscal 2027 budget leans too much on unsustainable fixes, and said political infighting within a condensed timeline before the Dec. 31 statutory deadline makes an on time budget with meaningful structural improvements hard to achieve. Uncertainty around the budget helped push a bond sale, originally scheduled for the third quarter, into early next year.
At an hours long Oct. 26 budget hearing, Gabrysch's answers highlighted disagreements with the administration. Johnson later described it as a technical debate over what counts as structural, saying, "The technical difference of interpretation on what was structural and what was not was actually worked out in a very thoughtful and engaged conversation," and pointed out that independent auditors have signed off on the city's finances each year.
Comptroller Michael Belsky, a longtime municipal market veteran, is serving as acting CFO and, the mayor said, has been actively involved in the budget process.
Why it matters for your portfolio
Chicago's rating hovers just above junk, and S&P's watch warning raises the odds of a cut if the 2027 fix relies on short term expedients. Lisa Washburn of Municipal Market Analytics said she cannot remember another major city that lost three CFOs within a single year in recent history, and warned, "If you can't price that correctly, that has the potential of reducing the investor base." Yale Law's David Schleicher highlighted the trust risk: "The worry is that people will cease trusting and therefore not be willing even with high interest rates to make loans." The bottom line: if trust erodes and a downgrade follows, thinner demand can push Chicago's borrowing costs higher, a clear headwind for anyone holding or eyeing the city's paper.
Markets and municipal finances can feel complex, so get the free Market Briefs in five minutes or less each morning
