For the first time in three years, housing prices in America have fallen for four straight weeks. If you were hoping that means you can buy a house for cheap, think again.
Mortgage rates have gone up while prices slipped, so the monthly cost of buying is not cheaper. Briefs Finance CEO Jaspreet Singh says the bigger mistake is counting on a house to make you rich at all.
In his view, a house is an expense and your investments are what build wealth. On November 17, he is hosting a free livestream that teaches investors how to use ChatGPT and Claude to research stocks like a pro.
Housing Prices Fell, but Mortgage Rates Went the Other Way
Many people assume mortgage rates move whenever the Federal Reserve raises or holds interest rates. That is not necessarily true.
The rate your bank charges is generally built from two pieces, and both have been going up:
- The 10-year Treasury yield. This is the interest rate the U.S. government pays when you lend it money.
- The spread. This is the extra interest the bank charges on top of that yield, and it is the bank's profit.
| Piece of your mortgage rate | Where it stands |
|---|---|
| 10-year Treasury yield | Around 5% |
| Spread | Approximately 2.3% |
| 30-year fixed mortgage rate | Around 7.2% |
Banks Are Charging a Wider Spread
The spread is higher now than it has been in the past. Banks are more concerned about the economy and about people's ability to pay back their mortgages.
Lenders Want More to Hold U.S. Debt
A Treasury is a loan to the U.S. government, and lenders ask for more interest when a loan feels riskier. Right now there are concerns about the U.S. dollar and about inflation, so people have been demanding higher rates.
Three recent headlines added to that pressure:
- A new inflation report showed inflation is not cooling.
- The war in the Middle East will probably continue, with high oil prices.
- Foreign buyers are investing less money into the United States.
When you hear about war and oil prices, you probably don't think about your mortgage rate. Jaspreet says they are directly connected, because inflation worries push the 10-year yield up.
The Fed's own rate feeds into that yield as well. Everybody hoped mortgage rates would fall by the end of the year, but one Fed member just said they are thinking about a jumbo interest rate hike before the year ends.
Falling Housing Prices Have Home Builders Hitting Pause
Higher mortgage rates are part of the reason home prices have dropped four weeks in a row. They are also making home builders ask whether they should be building more homes at all.
A subdivision is not finished in six weeks. It can take 12, 18, 24 or maybe 36 months, so a builder spends the money today and hopes there are buyers when the homes are done.
When builders can't tell where the economy is headed, they don't want to spend that money. Almost half have started cutting their prices, and many say they will stop building new homes.
Housing Prices in 2019, 2023 and 2026: Same House, Bigger Bill
Jaspreet compared the cost of buying the median house, the one in the middle of the market, in three different years.
| 2019 | 2023 | 2026 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Median house price | $227,000 | $409,000 | Around $389,000 |
| 30-year mortgage rate | About 3.9% | Around 6.8% | Around 7.2% |
| Monthly mortgage payment (20% down) | About $1,030 | $2,135 | Around $2,110 |
| Median household income | $68,700 | $80,600 | About $87,500 |
| Share of income going to the mortgage | 19% | About a third | Around 29% |
The house costs about $20,000 less than it did in 2023. The monthly payment is only about $25 cheaper, because the mortgage rate went up.
Incomes did grow over those years. The mortgage still takes around 29% of the median income today, compared with 19% in 2019.
That is why so many people feel poorer: the cost of owning a home grew faster than incomes. The payment has roughly doubled since 2019, so unless your income doubled too, Jaspreet says you are effectively "house poorer."
A Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac Sale Could Push Mortgage Rates Higher
Your bank does not want to wait 30 years to make its money on your mortgage. Here is what happens instead:
- You get a mortgage from your bank.
- The bank sells that mortgage to Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac.
- They bundle thousands of mortgages into one investment, called a mortgage-backed security.
- Big investors such as pension funds and foreign governments buy it.
Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac guarantee that the interest on those securities gets paid. They can make that promise because they are, in Jaspreet's words, "kind of backed" by the U.S. government, and that means by your tax dollars.
President Trump wants to end that government guarantee and sell Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac to investors on the stock market. The concern some people have is what that would do to mortgage rates.
A guaranteed investment carries less risk, so investors accept a lower return. Take the guarantee away and they will want a higher one.
Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac would then need more from the bank. The bank, in turn, would have to charge you a higher mortgage rate.
The plan still has to be approved, so we have to wait and see if it happens. For now, it is on President Trump's agenda.
Is It a Good Time to Buy a House While Housing Prices Slip?
Mortgage rates do not look like they will see a big drop anytime soon. Some people are even talking about a potential 8% mortgage rate, depending on what happens with inflation and the Fed.
Higher rates generally mean fewer buyers. Fewer buyers give you more room to negotiate, and you can use that as leverage.
Jaspreet's bigger piece of advice is not to try to time the market. He doesn't think of a house as an investment in the first place.
Why a House Is a Liability, Not an Investment
That idea comes as a shock, because for most people a house is their biggest and most expensive asset. Jaspreet says it as an investor who also used to be a realtor.
Buyers often ask their banker and their realtor for the biggest house they can buy. Both work on commission and a bigger deal means a bigger check, so the answer is often a bigger house.
It feels good, too. You get a bigger home for your family, and it seems like the best investment you can make because you can pay it off and pass it down.
The Bills Show Up After You Move In
A bigger house costs more to run, starting with the utilities. Then you want to renovate the kitchen, redo the basement, repaint and buy new furniture.
As the house gets older, it needs a new roof, a furnace, an AC unit or new windows. The money you planned to invest in the stock market, in rental properties or in a business idea goes to housing payments instead, and you end up house poor.
Your Mortgage Pays the Bank First
A mortgage is amortized, which means the bank front-loads the interest so it gets paid before you do. A $3,000 monthly payment is not $1,500 of interest and $1,500 of principal, the part that becomes your equity in the house.
For the first many years, almost every dollar goes to interest. It isn't until around year 15, depending on your mortgage rate, that half of the payment goes to principal.
A cash-out refinance starts the amortization over. People keep pulling money out and keep paying interest, so they never build true equity unless the home goes up in value.
Homes Don't Always Go Up in Value
Home prices fell very hard in the 2008 crash, and they are falling slightly now. Bad periods in the economy are when people need money most, and that is when some are forced to sell into falling prices.
Even a paid-off house still comes with property taxes and insurance, and both rise when the home's value rises. That is why many people inherit a paid-off house and then can't afford to keep it.
Buy the House for Memories and Let Your Investments Build Wealth
Jaspreet is not against buying a house. He thinks it is a great thing to do, and that it is better to buy than to rent.
The mistake is buying too big, too fast because you think it is the best investment in the world. Treat the house as a liability, an expense, and you buy something within your budget that still leaves money to invest.
You also analyze your investments differently than your house. That analysis is what Jaspreet's free November 17 livestream covers: how to use ChatGPT and Claude to research stocks like a pro.
Think this way and you stop worrying so much about the housing market or whether you are buying at the peak.
As your investments grow, they can pay for that big dream house. Until then, you buy a house to make memories, not to make you rich.




































































































