Cramming pets, a partner, and belongings into a one bedroom rental outside Cincinnati finally pushed Kelly MacDonald to shop for a place of her own. After meeting a would-be agent at a backyard get-together earlier this year, she asked her mom, who works in commercial real estate, to scrutinize the contract before signing.
Her mom spotted a $425 add-on. MacDonald did what she usually does and checked Reddit, where commenters warned it was a junk fee. As MacDonald put it, "She would sniff out bad vibes or things that might be weird." When it came time to close, she would not pay the $425 and instead got the seller to pick it up.
MacDonald ultimately closed on a five bedroom house with a fireplace on a quiet corner and a big yard for the dog, paying $445,000. Gazing at the front porch, she said, "Had to work hard for it," and later added, "I kind of feel guilty they paid for it," and, "I think the realtor should have paid for it."
These fees have been around for decades but are showing up more often, and now frequently hit both sides of the deal. The Consumer Policy Center says they appear in most home sales. Co author and fellow Wendy Gilch said, "It's been growing for so long." She added, "Consumers didn't really ask what it was for, or were told it was their cost," and said she has watched the practice spread nationwide, recalling that years ago a Dallas agent she knew did not see such fees in her market, but now does. The think tank estimates buyers and sellers together are paying nearly $2 billion a year and calls that figure conservative.
Brokerages often charge these fees to agents with the expectation they will pass them along to clients. One possible driver, according to the report, is brokerages competing for agents by offering better commission splits, then making up revenue with client fees. Some agents choose to cover the costs themselves. Concrete numbers are scarce, but the added charge can climb above $1,000 due at closing.
Watching out for hidden costs helps you protect and grow your financial future. Join Briefs Finance CEO Jaspreet Singh on September 29th for a FREE live investor workshop, How to Profit From A Dollar That's Losing its Value, where he shows how we're spotting investment opportunities as the dollar falls. Save your spot.
Plenty of agents dislike these charges. "I've experienced it and I think they're crap," said April Green, a South Florida agent with 15 years in the business. Early on, she saw colleagues tack on amounts like $495, saying, "They just put $495 or whatever and it was just because they could," and adding, "I've had a bad taste in my mouth with the admin fees since then, because what's it really for?" Complaints also surface on TikTok, where some agents call the fees "irritating" and "dumb." Agents earn commissions on home sales that are often more than $10,000 and typically split that with their brokerage, which is why extra fees can feel like a money grab to some.
There has also been litigation. This year, Florida buyers sued Compass over what they described as transaction fees, alleging the company added them illegally. Later, the buyers moved for dismissal, and the court closed the case. NPR sought comment from Compass, but the company did not provide one.
Because these charges hit at closing, they increase the cash you need on the day you get the keys. A $425 fee is a sliver of a typical U.S. home price that can often run north of $400,000, but for buyers scraping together funds for a down payment and inspections, it can bite. Fees can be added late in the process and not always clearly disclosed.
Sometimes brokerages expect agents to pass them on, sometimes agents absorb them, and sometimes the seller ends up paying. Either way, researchers say these line items have become common and add up to nearly $2 billion a year, which can change how much you plan to bring to the table and how you negotiate who covers what.
A steady plan that trims needless expenses can keep your savings working for you. Our CEO Jaspreet Singh is hosting a FREE live investor workshop, How to Profit From A Dollar That's Losing its Value, on September 29th. Sign up free to join him live.
