What is back in court
A commercial mortgage-backed security put together before the global financial crisis is now at the center of a London dispute almost a decade and a half after its debt first defaulted. The deal, Titan 2006-5 Plc, bundled eight property loans and was issued in 2006, with its Class A2 and A3 notes rated AAA by Fitch at the time. Today, Davidson Kempner and RFR hold those notes, respectively.
That strong start did not last. The biggest loan in Titan, secured by German multifamily properties, went into default in 2008, and the junior notes defaulted afterward. By 2015, Fitch had likewise deemed the senior notes owned by RFR and Davidson Kempner to be in default. Most of the other properties were sold or refinanced, leaving one asset still in play.
The last asset and why it is stuck
The remaining loan is tied to Quartier 206, an upscale Berlin mall whose architecture is by Pei Cobb Freed & Partners, opened in 1997. The property was initially overseen by German developer Anno August Jagdfeld and has suffered distress for over a decade, with control entangled in protracted court disputes between Jagdfeld and creditors. In Germany, Jagdfeld became well known for property funds marketed to small investors, among them a fund used to rebuild Berlin's Hotel Adlon.
A 2010 servicing report recorded that Jagdfeld granted rent breaks to relatives who were occupying space as tenants, and, combined with departures by other tenants, the value fell to €96.3 million from €181 million, below the debt. The asset was enforced upon and put into compulsory administration in 2011, but it still has not been sold to repay creditors. Court administered auctions have tried to move it, but legal disputes have repeatedly derailed sales.
An auction late last year failed to meet the reserve, and an April sale without a reserve was aborted after the court deemed the €40 million bid invalid, court filings indicate. Another auction is planned for next week.
When developments take time to unfold, staying informed helps you make better decisions, so sign up for Market Briefs
The Jagdfeld Group said the property was "100% let to first-class tenants whilst the Jagdfeld Group was in charge of its management." The spokesperson added, "We sought an amicable settlement with the creditors for a long time. As they rejected this, we - like any other company - attempted to enforce our rights in court. We have always been very cooperative."
The legal fight over control
RFR has taken Situs Group, the CMBS manager, to the High Court, alleging it was wrongly denied the chance to take control of the final asset and seeking at least €88.5 million from Situs. RFR contends the Titan documentation grants it a right to purchase the Quartier 206 loan at a fair value set by Situs.
"A sale of the Property at auction to a third party would deprive the purchase option of any practical value," RFR's lawyers said, adding that Situs "refused or failed to determine the Fair Value of the loan when requested to do so, thereby preventing the claimant from exercising the option to purchase the loan." RFR also claims Davidson Kempner Capital Management, a New York hedge fund and senior noteholder, unlawfully worked with Situs to thwart that option. Davidson Kempner declined to comment. Situs did not initially respond to requests for comment.
Why it matters for your portfolio
This is a late-cycle relic of pre-2008 finance still working through the courts, and who controls the last loan will shape recoveries and timing. An auction could finally move the asset, but if RFR secures the contractual right to buy the loan at fair value, the payout path could shift. The bottom line: legacy CMBS can tie up capital for years and hinge on legal interpretations as much as market prices.
When developments take time to unfold, get clear context every morning by subscribing to the free Market Briefs newsletter
