What dragged Q3 and what changes next
Materials names stumbled on margins in the third quarter, with nearly two thirds of S&P 500 materials companies reporting weaker-than-expected operating margins, per Bloomberg Intelligence. Executives largely blamed timing, saying many of the announced price increases have not yet fully hit reported results.
Pricing power was a frequent theme on third quarter calls, more than in any other sector. Companies passed through higher raw material and energy costs tied to tariffs and the Middle East conflict, while also cutting costs by closing plants and reducing headcount. Estimates cited were as of Nov. 18.
The setup for a rebound
Analysts expect materials margins to widen by 4.3 percentage points this year, second only to energy and technology, which benefited from stronger oil and artificial intelligence demand. BI analyst Jason Miner said the primary boost has come from price increases that followed the run up in oil, and because materials suppliers sit higher in the supply chain, they can lift prices on inputs that buyers cannot easily swap or delay. If oil recedes and selling prices hold, margins expand further.
Miner also cautioned the sectorwide lift from pricing may not last through next year, pointing to soft spots in autos, homebuilding and construction that could cap the recovery. "Prices shoot up and they drift down," he said.
When sector reports leave you with questions about future trends, sign up for the free Market Briefs today
Company-by-company signals
Management teams framed Q3 as a lag before pricing benefits show up. Sherwin-Williams expects a larger portion of its 8% September price increase to be reflected in reported results by midyear. Management at Nucor anticipates that pricing on its downstream offerings will continue to boost results well into 2027.
Steel Dynamics and Packaging Corp. of America said the latest round of price hikes should underpin results next year. Having boosted pricing on the majority of paper grades this year, Smurfit Westrock believes those hikes, together with cost reductions, will more than offset about 700 million dollars in higher freight and energy expenses as the company heads into 2027, CEO Tony Smurfit said. "When we're in price-increase mode, we're 100% focused on price increase because those opportunities don't come along that often and that's incredibly important to our business in the long term," Packaging Corp. CEO Mark Kowlzan said.
Demand mostly held up. Dow reported that volumes - setting aside supply limitations connected to the Middle East conflict - were "resilient," though it cited soft housing and elevated interest rates as the primary risks for next year. PPG CEO Tim Knavish was cautious on pricing as a near term boost, saying, "I would certainly not assume price inflation to be a tailwind in the short term because we've still got some work to do." Jefferies analyst Laurence Alexander wrote that, by the first half of 2027 at the latest, PPG's pricing should offset higher costs, and roughly 100 million dollars of restructuring savings will bolster margins. For Sherwin-Williams, Alexander anticipates that market share gains and price hikes will more than make up for a weaker backdrop next year.
What it means for your portfolio
In plain English: pricing power plus cost cuts are rebuilding profitability across materials, with several companies pointing to benefits that extend into 2027 and analysts tracking a sector margin step up through mid November. The flip side is that the pricing tailwind may fade next year, and any cooling in oil or demand in autos, homebuilding and construction could slow the climb. For materials exposure, watch how sticky pricing proves, the pace of cost reductions, and what housing and rates signal about the next leg.
To keep up without spending hours each day, get our free Market Briefs newsletter that sums it all in minutes
