Why managers are rotating into agency MBS
Treasury yields climbed for much of the year, pushing mortgage rates higher, then fell sharply in recent weeks. That back and forth adds uncertainty that weighs on mortgage-bond pricing. Since late June, the extra yield on newly produced 30-year Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac bonds has widened by about 0.2 percentage point, and overall agency MBS spreads are near their widest of 2024 and about 0.15 percentage point above the decade average, Bloomberg data show.
In that context, mortgages look inexpensive, whereas corporate bonds sit about 0.2 percentage point richer than their own 10-year norm. Firms like Vanguard and TCW are leaning into agencies over company debt to capture that relative value if yields calm.
How prepayments are reshaping risk
Mortgages usually react hard when yields fall because refinancing speeds up, returning principal early and cutting income. But yields have run up so much since 2022 - and again in recent weeks - that most loans in today's pools are not refinanceable, reducing that downside.
The upshot: agency MBS show almost no negative convexity right now. In plain English, if yields drop, they can rally more like corporate bonds. Bloomberg data show this prepayment sensitivity near the lowest levels in several decades.
As of October, only 1.5% of outstanding mortgages carried more than a 25 basis point incentive to refinance, Citi says, the lowest in two and a half years - or since April 2024 - except for September. That's not the case here.
When uncertainty touches bond markets, staying informed matters, so sign up for the free Market Briefs to get clarity
Portfolio moves and market forces
Positioning is already shifting. By late September, Vanguard moved overweight mortgages versus credit, and Wellington Management has been adding in recent months as volatility increased. At TCW, the firm's biggest, highest-conviction overweight spans pools backed by guarantors such as Freddie Mac and Ginnie Mae, while corporate bonds make up the largest underweight.
Among the large funds Citigroup tracks, MBS weightings climbed 0.9 percentage point in September - the largest month-over-month rise since June 2024. Meanwhile, US companies have issued a record 1.9 trillion dollars of blue-chip bonds this year as they build AI infrastructure. That deluge has made corporate bonds a larger slice of the US high-grade market than mortgages, an unusual turn given that in 2009 the market value of the MBS index was nearly twice that of the corporate credit market, FHN Financial notes based on Bloomberg index data.
Higher borrowing costs are cooling housing demand, which slows new mortgage originations and supports prices by limiting fresh supply. At Brandywine Global Investment Management, portfolio manager Tracy Chen described the supply decline as "That is a great favorable to the market technical," adding that government-sponsored buyers such as Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac have dry powder to step in if spreads widen further. Despite the recent selloff in investment-grade corporate bonds, TCW's Peter Van Gelderen still favors agencies, citing the record-tight spread gap between the two. "Let's say you're anxious about any of a number of things, from overseas wars, the economy, AI adoption risk," he said. "Agency MBS are much less directly exposed to those risks than corporate credit."
Comparing sectors is a challenge because they work differently, said AllianceBernstein portfolio manager Fahd Malik. But on extra yield alone, mortgages look better tactically. "October gave MBS investors plenty to cheer, recouping about half of the prior month's underperformance," Goldman Sachs strategists wrote. They added that this strength positions agency MBS as a defensive choice when corporate-bond spreads are whipsawing.
Recent performance and what it could mean for your portfolio
It has not been a smooth ride. From July through September, mortgage bonds lagged, with the MBS index down 3.38% in September, placing it within the 10 weakest months for total and excess returns over the past four decades. Still, Alex Payne notes that after sharp three-month drops, the sector has almost always snapped back with positive excess returns as crossover buyers shift from Treasuries or corporate credit back into MBS. TCW's Van Gelderen also notes that owning discount coupons positions investors for mean reversion while being relatively shielded from volatility stemming from investor sentiment on AI or from the expansion of AI data-center infrastructure, and he calls agency mortgages "one of the best mean reverting sources of value in a long time."
The bottom line: mortgages look inexpensive relative to corporates, spreads are wide, prepayment risk is unusually muted, and big managers have already tilted that way. Goldman's call for lighter supply, steadier rates and potential bank demand only adds to the near term setup.
Markets move for many reasons, and a short briefing helps, so join the free Market Briefs newsletter today
