What Moscow put on the table
Russia said any settlement cannot include Ukraine joining NATO. Sergei Ryabkov told Tass that even a quasi-membership formula or a so called creative workaround tied to NATO is "an unacceptable option for us," adding Kyiv needs to accept that Moscow will not shift on this. Once that is understood, he said, "the question of security guarantees can be discussed." He emphasized Russia is open to talks, just not ones about Ukraine entering the alliance.
Washington, meanwhile, has been urging European partners to negotiate a broader European security framework to be included in any settlement over Ukraine, something the Kremlin has long pushed for. Vladimir Putin has repeatedly insisted Ukraine must never enter NATO, and he conveyed to Witkoff and Kushner that any non-Ukrainian troops stationed on Ukraine's territory pose an unacceptable risk to Russia's security.
The diplomatic circuit
Ryabkov took part in U.S.-run peace talks alongside Ukraine in Abu Dhabi last week, the first such gathering since February. Afterward, US envoys Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner traveled by air to Moscow to see Putin, and later met with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy in Dublin.
Subsequently, the pair updated Zelenskyy and European leaders during a so-called Coalition of the Willing session in Berlin on Thursday, following a conversation between Putin and US President Donald Trump about the war during meetings in China. People with knowledge of the discussion, who asked not to be named, said Trump unexpectedly called into the Berlin session from Air Force One and said the talks were productive, adding that Putin seeks to end the war. After Thursday's meeting, Kushner said, "I think we've gotten the Russians comfortable with that concept where any security guarantee for Ukraine would be based on Article 5."
In times of geopolitical uncertainty it's helpful to get clear, concise updates, so sign up for the free Market Briefs newsletter today.
Putin on Thursday said Russia invited European representatives to Moscow for discussions, saying, "We need to understand what Europe will bring to these negotiations." Bloomberg earlier reported that E3 officials - France, Germany and the UK - were likewise weighing a possible meeting with Moscow.
What Kyiv and Europe are seeking
Zelenskyy said the envoys asked whether Ukraine would cede the Donbas to Russia in exchange for NATO membership, calling it "the first time this had been raised." He said Kyiv views as an "absolute minimum" security guarantees patterned after NATO's Article 5, and added that the US officials suggested something "similar to Articles 4 and 5 of NATO," while stressing Ukraine needs more clarity.
European officials see firm guarantees as central to any final deal but do not want to blend ceasefire talks with wider security discussions, insisting Russia must halt the fighting first. French President Emmanuel Macron said Thursday it is time to reopen the discussion of Ukraine's potential NATO membership, noting, "Today, this question arises even for us Europeans." Kyiv's position is that only iron clad pledges from allies can credibly deter a renewed assault by Moscow.
Why it matters for investors
The gap remains wide between Kyiv's demand for binding protection and Moscow's blanket rejection of any NATO track. Watch for signals from the Berlin briefings, whether Europeans take up Putin's invitation to Moscow, and how any Article 5 based concepts are described by negotiators. Security guarantees sit at the center of paths for sanctions, European defense spending, and risk premia across the region.
When big global developments matter to portfolios and policy, stay informed with our free Market Briefs that distill the essentials.
