The changing dynamics in fundraising reveal why Apollo Global Management Inc. now views direct lending as just a small component of its broader investment strategy. The firm has used food analogies to emphasize that most of its private credit holdings carry investment-grade ratings.
Fundraising for non-traded BDCs totaled $2 billion in Q2, down 82% year-over-year from $11 billion, according to Robert A. Stanger & Co. This marks the lowest point since 2020, when the market was considerably smaller and today's largest funds had not yet begun their capital-raising efforts.
Meanwhile, redemption requests reached unprecedented levels, with investors seeking to withdraw $23 billion during the same period. Fund managers maintained their 5% limits on withdrawals. While some private credit managers indicated during recent earnings discussions that redemption requests are slowing, the upcoming late-August reports from non-traded funds will provide a clearer picture of whether the pressure is genuinely subsiding.
Volatile markets test patience, but the free Always Be Buying E-Book builds wealth through consistency.
"The fundraising environment has tightened considerably, redemption requests continue to run high, and the strain is showing up in net flows and overall market size," said Kevin Gannon, CEO of Stanger.
Recent earnings from publicly traded BDCs suggest the sector has avoided the worst-case scenarios that some had feared. Companies have focused on cleaning up their balance sheets, including writing down underperforming assets, and their stock prices have generally responded favorably.
As managers return more capital to investors and originate fewer loans, private credit firms are exploring alternatives to traditional direct lending. Several alternative asset managers have deliberately distinguished their broader operations from direct lending during recent earnings calls.
Blue Owl Capital Inc. reported that direct lending now represents just 35% of its assets under management, down from roughly half two years ago, while highlighting growth in its data center lending operations. Blackstone Inc. similarly pointed to artificial intelligence-related investments as a key driver of its performance, even as management fee growth from its credit division slowed.
This strategic shift comes as lenders confront their most significant test in retail-focused direct lending products, which have been substantial fee generators. For BDCs that pool direct loans, reduced fundraising has constrained their ability to make new investments. This affects both private vehicles and their publicly traded counterparts, although the latter benefit from access to permanent capital.
The contraction in direct lending reflects broader market adjustments. Investors who poured money into these products during their rapid expansion are now seeking liquidity, forcing managers to balance redemption requests against portfolio stability. The 5% withdrawal limits, while unpopular with some investors, have helped prevent forced asset sales during volatile periods.
As the market continues to adjust, the ability to identify new lending opportunities while managing existing portfolios will likely separate the most successful firms from their peers.
When markets drop, consistent investing wins, so get the free Always Be Buying E-Book.