What Kalshi and Novig want from states
Even as Kalshi battles dozens of states in court, it is simultaneously asking those jurisdictions to help block problem gamblers from its exchange. The New York company and smaller rival Novig sent a letter to 35 states seeking access to state self-exclusion lists - registries of people who ask to be blocked from betting sites.
Their argument: many state safeguards don't apply to prediction markets because those platforms fall under federal oversight as derivatives exchanges. As their attorneys put it, "Today's patchwork of separate state lists leaves gaps that at-risk people can fall through." They also wrote, "A single federal self-exclusion program can protect every person who asks for it, on every platform, in every state," and set a Dec. 15 deadline for replies.
How the data would be handled and who signed on
Kalshi keeps its own exclusion program through IC360, and about 1,800 people have opted to block themselves from prediction markets. Kalshi and Novig said they will give states those names so they can join the tens of thousands already listed in state systems. In return, the companies want states to share their lists so IC360 can ingest them after confidentiality agreements are in place. The letter says IC360 will store barred bettors in "hashed" form to protect sensitive information.
Polymarket - named by IC360 as a platform partner and often characterized as Kalshi's largest competitor - did not sign onto the letter. A spokesperson for Polymarket did not reply to a request for comment.
When policy and markets intersect, get clarity with the free Market Briefs newsletter that explains economy, markets, crypto, and real estate quickly
The regulatory backdrop
Prediction markets have surged in popularity, and counselors who focus on gambling disorders warn the platforms can trigger relapse, partly because state exclusion systems do not automatically cover federally regulated exchanges like Kalshi and Novig. Several states have sued prediction market firms, arguing they should be overseen by gambling regulators so they must offer protections equivalent to what online sportsbooks provide.
Kalshi contends it operates as a financial exchange rather than a gambling operator and, as a result, should not fall under gambling regulations. Even so, the company has tried to mirror some safeguards, including its IC360 program, and it is part of the National Council on Problem Gambling. That has not quieted critics: when Massachusetts sued Kalshi in September, the state argued that even after the company created a self-exclusion list, it still did not offer resources for bettors "seeking responsible gambling messaging or help for financial loss or gambling addiction." As Attorney General Andrea Campbell said, "Sports wagering comes with significant risk of addiction and financial loss and must be strictly regulated to mitigate public health consequences."
Investor takeaway
Two contrasts define the fight: Kalshi allows users aged 18 and up, while many gambling sites require 21, and federal oversight means state tools do not always reach these platforms. The companies want to close those gaps by trading exclusion data with states, while keeping identities protected, and have asked for answers by Dec. 15.
If you want to follow regulatory shifts without getting bogged down, subscribe to our free Market Briefs for a five-minute daily summary
