What happened to Mars crude
At the start of the Iran war, when the Strait of Hormuz was shut, supply hiccups pushed buyers toward Mars - a Gulf of Mexico grade akin to Middle Eastern crude - lifting it to a never-before-seen premium over West Texas Intermediate. Up until late February, prior to the U.S. and Israel beginning their war in Iran, Mars usually traded at a discount to WTI.
The tide turned fast. Within a span of less than a month, Mars shifted from carrying a $10 premium to sitting $4 below WTI futures, marking the sharpest discount since late September. Over time, the spread has averaged a modest 41 cent premium.
Why prices have fallen
More heavy sour barrels are hitting the market. Output growth in Venezuela and Canada has weighed on global prices, allowing U.S. refiners on the Gulf Coast and in the Midwest to gain from increased shipments from Canada and Latin America. Meanwhile, higher freight rates are eroding prices at loading points, and flows out of the Persian Gulf have risen.
When energy markets and global flows can shift quickly, sign up for the free Market Briefs newsletter to stay informed
Even with Mars cheaper, Asia is not jumping in. Traders say higher Middle Eastern availability leaves Mars uneconomical to import. For February delivery to Northeast Asia, Mars was indicated about 12 to 13 dollars per barrel above the Dubai benchmark, roughly 10 dollars more than similar Saudi barrels, and at least one other Middle Eastern seller has slashed offer prices.
Market executives are taking note. In October, Randy Hawkins, Valero's head of crude supply, said, "Incremental supply looks to be dominated by heavier and more sour barrels, especially out of Canada, Venezuela, and the Middle East," That same month, Brian Mandell, who serves as executive vice president for marketing and commercial at Phillips 66, told analysts, "It's a race to the bottom."
Canada's West Coast outlet is surging: this month the pipeline that carries oil-sands crude to Pacific export markets is running at a record 960,000 barrels per day, 8 percent above its stated capacity. Loadings at the Westridge terminal near Vancouver are scheduled for 34 vessels in November, compared with 31 in October.
What it means for refiners, producers, and your portfolio
Lower-priced heavy crude benefits refiners, who are already earning record profits because the Iran war has disrupted global fuel markets, but it puts a squeeze on producers of dense, high-sulfur oil. "We're basically going to have to be a price taker," said Sable Offshore Corp. chief executive Jim Flores earlier this month. The company pumps heavy oil off California.
Exports remain strong. U.S. crude shipments of both heavy and light grades are holding near historic highs at about 4 million barrels a day on a four week basis, below the weekly record above 6 million set in April yet well above the post 2015 average near 3 million. The bottom line: more heavy sour supply from Venezuela, Canada, and the Middle East has pushed Mars from record premium to deep discount, reshaping spreads that feed straight into refiner margins and upstream cash flow.
If you want clear five-minute updates on the economy, stocks, crypto and real estate, get the free Market Briefs today
