What the Bank is doing now
Speaking at Bloomberg's Credit Forum in London on Wednesday, Nathanaël Benjamin said the work is shifting to how risks can ripple through the system when players act together, not how any one firm holds up. As he put it, "We're interested in the system-wide behaviors, how the ecosystem acts, how people's actions interact with each other and does that amplify shocks or does that absorb them?" It is "not a classic stress test where we are testing the resilience of individual institutions."
Benjamin holds the role of the Bank's executive director with responsibility for financial stability, strategy and risk. He said the central bank is nearing the release of preliminary outputs from its system-wide exploratory scenario on private credit. He also pointed out that private capital provides an "outsized contribution" to funding the UK economy, and "therefore the risks that come with it have to be understood and have to be managed."
The SWES and the private credit backdrop
This SWES is the first stress test the private credit industry has faced. A total of 46 participants are involved, including Apollo Global Management Inc., Goldman Sachs Asset Management, and Oaktree Capital Management LP.
Earlier this year, the $1.8 trillion private credit market had a rough patch as some retail investors were unnerved by the degree of software exposure. That spurred attempts to pull money from retail-oriented funds, and many managers responded by capping withdrawals. Benjamin added he is not worried about defaults in isolation, saying, "Defaults are a feature not a bug of the system." What he wants to monitor is any amplification that stems from how financing is structured. In 2024, he also warned that opaque valuations in private capital can create material risks.
When financial systems interact, staying informed matters, so sign up for the free Market Briefs to keep perspective.
How market participants are reacting
Industry voices pushed back on the idea the asset class is brittle. Matt Theodorakis, a partner at Ares Management Corp., a participant in the SWES, said private credit has already been through multiple exams: "Starting in 2020, whether it was Covid, whether it was kind of the hangover when we reopened the world post-Covid, then double-digit inflation, then interest rates, which shot up, these were just incredible tests on our books, on our strategy, on the fund structures." He added, "The backlog of redemptions is significantly lower than it was six months ago. And I feel like we're on the other side of it."
Standard Life Plc's chief credit officer, Michela Bariletti, said some of the earlier strain reflected a need to better explain the asset class: "We all spent a lot of time educating the market and our investment committee over the past nine months." Looking ahead, she expects more defaults if rates stay higher for longer. "In small and medium sized enterprises, only the strongest will actually succeed." Still, that is part of credit investing: "If you don't have any default in or any restructuring in your portfolio and you are a credit investor, you haven't taken enough risk."
Matthew Harvey, who runs middle market direct lending globally at PGIM Inc., said the cracks showing in parts of credit are not "systemic or macro," but rather "stylistic," such as portfolios concentrated in one sector. "We continue to see on average mid-to-high single digit earnings and top line growth," across our portfolio today, Harvey said.
What investors should watch next
The focus now is on whether market structure can turn routine credit losses into wider stress. The Bank is nearing interim findings from its system-wide exercise, and the lens is squarely on collective behavior. For portfolios, that means regulators are watching linkages and feedback loops, not just firm-by-firm balance sheets.
With complex credit linkages, a quick read can help you stay grounded, so join our free Market Briefs newsletter today.
