At first glance, the June unemployment rate decline seemed like a bright spot in an otherwise disappointing jobs report, but the improvement was misleading. The reason is that the drop in unemployment to 4.2% - the lowest figure in twelve months - resulted mainly from a wave of workers leaving the market entirely, per Thursday's BLS release.
The share of Americans aged 16 and over who are working or actively seeking work fell to 61.5%, a level not seen since March 2021. Discounting the pandemic period, that is the lowest participation rate in half a century.
Get your free investing masterclass bonus when you join Market Briefs, our free daily newsletter
According to the establishment survey - which tallies filled positions - employment rose by 57,000 in June. In contrast, the household survey, which measures the number of employed individuals, dropped by 507,000. Compared to a year ago, the labor force has contracted by more than one million, the employed count is down by 1.06 million, and the unemployed population has increased by 40,000. The employment-to-population ratio decreased to 59% in June, its lowest point since October 2021.
RBC's head of U.S. economics, Mike Reid, attributed the labor force decline to a "massive exodus" caused by multiple factors. "The unemployment rate fell to 4.2% as both the number of unemployed workers and the size of the labor force pulled back," Reid wrote. "This may well be a story of retirements but could also be a story of prior job seekers dropping out of the labor force."
Some analysts point to a declining influx of foreign-born workers and the ongoing retirement of older generations, including baby boomers and Gen X, as possible causes for the participation decline.
Dan North, an economist at Allianz focused on North America, commented on the data, saying, "What really affects me is not so much the unemployment rate. What's an important development is the participation rate, and this is a big leg down in one month, and over the past year it's a pretty big leg down. I think this is a more important number." He added, "Looking at the statistics now, that argument doesn't hold up so well. I hate to use the word 'alarming.'"
Heather Long, the lead economist at Navy Federal Credit Union, observed in a written commentary, "It was shocking to see 720,000 people stop looking for work entirely and the hospitality sector shed jobs. It's a better job market than a year ago, but opportunities are limited."
Several economists noted that the June figures seem unusual, citing the sharp drop in leisure and hospitality employment as an indication that the data may be noisy. However, the participation rate figures reflect an ongoing pattern.
Subscribe to Market Briefs, our free daily newsletter, and claim your bonus investing masterclass
