NEWS / Stock

Judge Rules Meta Doesn't Hold Social Media Monopoly, Dismisses FTC Case

Briefs Finance

Published Nov 18, 2025

A blue candlestick chart with white arrows highlights Tesla’s strong quarter and introduces cheaper models, representing shifting financial market trends.

Summary:

Judge James Boasberg ruled the FTC failed to prove Meta currently holds monopoly power in social networking, dismissing the five-year-old case
The FTC had sought to force Meta to divest Instagram (bought for $1 billion in 2012) and WhatsApp (acquired for $19 billion in 2014)
Boasberg sided with Meta's argument that TikTok and YouTube now serve as major competitors in social media

The Ruling

Meta won its antitrust case against the FTC Tuesday. Judge James Boasberg ruled the agency failed to prove Meta holds a monopoly in social networking.

"The agency must show that it continues to hold such power now," Boasberg wrote. "The FTC has not done so."

The case started five years ago. It focused on Meta's purchases of Instagram and WhatsApp.

What the FTC Wanted

The FTC said Meta shouldn't have been allowed to buy Instagram for $1 billion in 2012. It also questioned the $19 billion WhatsApp purchase in 2014.

The agency wanted those companies separated from Meta.

The Problem

The judge said the FTC needed to prove Meta is breaking antitrust law today. Not years ago when social media worked differently.

Boasberg sided with Meta's argument. The company now faces real competition from TikTok and YouTube.

The Market Shift

Social media has changed dramatically. Users have moved heavily toward video content.

"People treat TikTok and YouTube as substitutes for Facebook and Instagram," Boasberg wrote. "The FTC offers no empirical evidence of substitution whatsoever."

The most-used parts of Meta's apps now look just like TikTok and YouTube.

The Reaction

"The deck was always stacked against us," said Joe Simonson, the FTC's director of public affairs. "We are reviewing all our options."

Meta shares fell less than 1% Tuesday. The stock is up about 2% for the year.

The Bottom Line

Meta won because the judge said the FTC must prove current monopoly power, not past dominance. TikTok and YouTube have changed the competitive landscape since Meta bought Instagram and WhatsApp over a decade ago.