Value Investing 101 - Your Complete Guide to Buying Quality Stocks on Sale

You've heard it a thousand times: "Buy low, sell high."

But what does "low" actually mean? And how do you know when you're getting a deal versus investing in a company in decline?

This is where value investing comes in - and it's how Warren Buffett turned Berkshire Hathaway into a $900+ billion empire.

Below we'll explain what value investing is, how to identify a value stock, and how to value one.

Want to find other potential stock market investing opportunities?

Our market analysts are researching new market shifts every week, and giving you new investing inspiration before the rest of Wall Street catches on.

Learn more and subscribe to Market Briefs Pro.

What Is Value Investing? The Core Principle

Value investing is buying stocks for less than they're worth.

It's not about finding the cheapest stock price. It's about finding the gap between what a company is worth (its intrinsic value) and what the market is currently charging for it.

Here's a real-world example:

Imagine a couple owns a house worth $500,000. They're divorcing, and one spouse needs to move to Florida immediately. They list it for $450,000 to sell fast.

Two years later, the market stabilizes, the neighborhood improves, and someone sells that same house for $600,000.

That's value investing.

You bought something below its true worth, held it, and sold when the price reflected (or exceeded) its actual value.

The Apple Example: Value Investing in Action

Back in December 2005, Apple stock traded at around $2.65 per share (adjusted for splits).

Not every investor saw the potential.

But some value investors looked deeper and saw:

• Strong fundamentals.
• Innovative products.
• A visionary CEO in Steve Jobs.
• A stock price that didn't reflect the company's potential.

By January 2025, Apple was trading at $243 per share.

That's value investing. Investors look for key indicators for stocks that have potential and try to spot what other investors are missing right now.

Price vs. Value: Why They're Not the Same Thing

We mentioned this a bit before, but it’s worth restating: Price does NOT equal value.

Look at Booking Holdings - trading at $5,332.80 per share as of May 2025. Is that expensive or cheap?

You can't tell from the price alone.

A stock's price is determined by:

1. Shares outstanding - How many shares exist.
2. Supply and demand - How many people want to buy vs. sell.
3. Market sentiment - How investors feel about the company's future.

Remember Zoom during the economic lockdowns of 2020 and 2021? The stock skyrocketed from $100 to $500+ as everyone worked from home.

Did Zoom become 5x more valuable as a company overnight? No. But the market was willing to pay that premium based on future expectations.

They provided a product that everyone needed at the time and it looked like it could be essential forever.

When those expectations changed, the stock crashed back down - as of January 5th 2026, the stock is trading at around $86 per share.

How to Identify Value Stocks: The 3-Step Process

Step 1: Look for Value Markers

Value stocks share specific characteristics that separate them from speculative plays:

✓ Consistent revenue over time - McDonald's isn't revolutionary anymore, but they've served billions of customers for decades - that stability = steady growing profits over time.

✓ Established brand recognition - Nike's swoosh logo commands premium prices. That's a moat - a competitive advantage that's nearly impossible to replicate.

Chances are, you can go to almost any continent in the world and someone will be able to identify the Nike logo, without ever even saying the company’s name.

✓ Strong competitive advantages - Warren Buffett always asks: "If I gave a competitor $100 billion, could they beat this company?" If the answer is no, that's a moat.

✓ Dividend payments - Companies that pay consistent dividends are typically mature, profitable, and shareholder-friendly.

✓ Low debt levels -  Less debt means more financial flexibility during downturns.

Companies like Campbell's Soup, Coca-Cola, and Pepsi aren't sexy. But they've historically been reliable. 

Reliability reduces risk - so while they may not have the same growth potential as a tech company, they offer a consistent value that may help investors profit over time.

Step 2: Identify When the Stock Is "On Sale"

Just because a company has value markers doesn't mean you should buy it today. You need the price to be right.

Example: COVID-19 Market Crash (March 2020)

The S&P 500 fell 34% in weeks.

Value investors asked: "Did Amazon suddenly become less valuable? Did Apple's business fundamentally change?"

For a large portion of the market, the answer was no. They were temporarily on sale because of market-wide panic, not fundamental problems.

For some other companies (airlines, cruise lines), yes - their businesses were genuinely disrupted.

Example: 2025 Tariff Announcement

When President Trump announced major tariffs in 2025, tech stocks got hammered. The Nasdaq entered bear market territory a few weeks after the announcements.

Were these companies suddenly 20% worse? No. But the market was pricing in uncertainty about supply chains and future earnings.

For value investors with cash, this created buying opportunities.

Step 3: Run the Numbers (Fundamental Analysis)

You can't just feel like a stock is cheap. You need to calculate valuation metrics. Let’s break down two examples using real numbers to determine if they are value stocks or not.

The Two Essential Value Investing Metrics

P/E Ratio (Price-to-Earnings)

Formula: Stock Price ÷ Earnings Per Share (EPS)

This tells you how much you're paying for each dollar of profit. Using the P/E ratio helps investors to determine if a stock is undervalued or overpriced based on its earnings.

If it’s undervalued, then it may be a potential bargain.

Example: Disney

Note: All numbers below are from Q2 2025.

• Stock price: $110.
• Net income: $4.972 billion.
• Shares outstanding: 1.81 billion.
• EPS: $4.972B ÷ 1.81B = $2.75.
• P/E ratio: $110 ÷ $2.75 = 40.

What does P/E = 40 mean? Investors are paying $40 for every $1 Disney earns.

Interpreting P/E Ratios:

Disney's P/E of 40 suggests the market expects significant future growth or is willing to pay a premium for Disney's brand strength.

But context matters:

• Compare to Disney's historical P/E (Is 40 normal or unusually high?).
• Compare to competitors (How does this stack up against Netflix, Comcast?).
• Compare to the S&P 500 average (typically 15-20).

Example: Ford vs. GM

• Ford P/E: 8.30.
• GM P/E: 7.02.

Both are lower than Disney's 40 and below Buffett's typical range.

Does that make them better value investments? Not necessarily - these low P/E ratios might reflect concerns about:

• Electric vehicle transition costs.
• Competition from Tesla and Chinese automakers.
• Cyclical business models with thin profit margins.

Or they might represent genuine buying opportunities.

Keep in mind - P/E should not be used in a vacuum. Professional investors use multiple different valuation metrics to determine a stock's true worth.

P/E is just one of the simplest - some investors swear by it while others never use it. Investors should understand the limitations of all valuation metrics, along with the value of each.

P/B Ratio (Price-to-Book)

Formula: Stock Price ÷ Book Value Per Share

This tells you how much you're paying relative to the company's actual net worth (assets minus liabilities). Again, the goal is to try and find a value that is not reflected in the stock’s price.

Example: Pfizer

• Stock price: $23.32.
• Shareholder equity: $88.2 billion.
• Shares outstanding: 5.67 billion.
• Book value per share: $88.2B ÷ 5.67B = $15.55.
• P/B ratio: $23.32 ÷ $15.55 = 1.49.

Interpreting P/B Ratios:

Pfizer's P/B of 1.49 is moderate. The market could be seeing value beyond physical assets - like drug pipelines, patents, and R&D capabilities.

Some tech companies have P/B ratios of 10, 20, or higher because their value is almost entirely intangible (software, data, brand).

Which Metrics Should You Use?

P/E ratio works best for: Companies with positive earnings.
P/B ratio works best for: Asset-heavy companies (banks, manufacturers).

Alternative metrics:

• P/S ratio (Price-to-Sales): For unprofitable companies.
• EV/EBITDA: For companies with heavy debt loads.

Different investors use different metrics. Choose what makes sense for the company you're analyzing.

Value Traps: What to Avoid

Not every cheap stock is a buying opportunity.

Value traps are stocks that look like bargains but are actually companies in serious decline.

Red Flag #1: Falling Earnings

Look at The Gap. Revenue has been essentially flat or declining for years.

When earnings are falling or turning negative, that's often a sign of deeper problems:

• Products becoming irrelevant.
• Losing market share to competitors.
• Broken business model.

A low stock price doesn't necessarily make it a value opportunity - it makes it a risky bet on a struggling company.

Red Flag #2: No Innovation

Companies that fail to innovate get left behind.

Examples:

• Hertz - Failed to adapt to changing transportation trends.
• BlackBerry - Couldn't compete when smartphones evolved.

It doesn't matter how strong they were in the past. If they're not adapting, they're in trouble.

Red Flag #3: Weak Moat

A "moat" is a competitive advantage that protects a company from rivals.

Strong moats:

• Coca-Cola's global distribution network and brand recognition.
• Amazon's logistics infrastructure and Prime ecosystem.

If a company doesn't have a moat, competitors can easily steal market share.

Is Value Investing Right for You?

Value investing requires three key personality traits:

1. Patience

Value stocks don't double overnight. They compound slowly over years.

The point: Both growth investing and value investing strategies work at different times, sometimes even at the same time. Investors just need to decide their mindset when purchasing a stock.

Are you buying it for growth, or because of its hidden value?

Typically value investing delivers consistent returns with lower risk over long periods. But the returns usually are not as explosive as growth stocks.

2. Discipline

You need to stick to your strategy even when everyone else is chasing hot stocks.

In 2023-2024, Nvidia (AI) and Eli Lilly (weight-loss drugs) were skyrocketing - Everyone was talking about them.

As a value investor, you have to resist FOMO and ask: "Do these companies fit my value criteria?"

Because chances are, if the rest of the market is talking about a hot stock, the opportunity has probably passed.

Assess your goals, risk tolerance, and always do your own analysis/research before purchasing shares in any company.

That will help you decide if it’s right for your portfolio.

3. Rationality

Fear and greed destroy value investors - so keeping your emotions in check is key.

You need to analyze numbers objectively and make logical decisions - even when the market is panicking or euphoric.

And don’t be afraid to cut a stock if it’s not working - cutting your losses is hard, but sometimes, it’s better to sell then to lose out on future opportunities because you're bogged down by a losing stock.

Time Investment Required

Here’s the thing about value investing though: It takes time, roughly 5-10 hours per week, and you have to take an active approach in your portfolio.

Value investing requires researching:

• Financial statements.
• Calculating metrics.
• Staying informed about company news and industry trends.
• Monitoring economic conditions.

If you're working full-time, raising kids, and juggling other responsibilities, do you have that time?

If not, that's okay. That's what index funds and passive investing are for.

But if you DO have the time and enjoy the research, value investing might be perfect for you.

Our market analysts research stocks every day, and show you the data in Market Briefs Pro

Subscribe to Market Briefs Pro here.

The Warren Buffett Approach

Nobody embodies value investing better than Warren Buffett - he’s one of the most successful investors of all time.

And his approach to investing is simple.

Buffett learned from Benjamin Graham (author of The Intelligent Investor) and has practiced value investing for over 70 years.

Find wonderful companies at fair prices, or fair companies at wonderful prices. 

Buy them.

Hold them.

Let compounding work.

Famous Buffett investments:

• Bank of America.
• Coca-Cola.
• Apple.
• American Express.
• Geico.

These weren't speculative bets on hot startups. They were established, profitable companies with strong moats trading at reasonable prices.

Sometimes he bought during market downturns (everything on sale). 

Other times he bought temporarily out-of-favor companies.

He didn’t always buy companies with 15 P/E ratios either. Sometimes, he paid higher because he felt the opportunity was worth it.

But in every case, he was buying value.

The Bottom Line

Value investing isn't about getting rich quick. It's about building wealth consistently through patience, discipline, and rational analysis.

When you buy quality companies at reasonable prices and hold them for years, compounding does the heavy lifting.

Warren Buffett proved this works - but whether it works for you depends on your personality, time compartment to invest, and even a little luck.

Because the reality is - even if you do everything right as a value investor, a stock could still fall.

Markets are unpredictable and no investment is ever guaranteed. So never invest more than you can afford to lose.

Still, the question is: Are you willing to put in the research and resist the temptation to chase hot stocks?

If so, value investing might be your path to building wealth.

The reality is though - there’s a lot of different stock market investing opportunities out there.

Our market analysts are spotting potential stocks before the rest of the market and giving you the actual data and research you need to make an investment decision.

Subscribe to Market Briefs Pro to learn more about these individual stocks that may outpace the market in 2026.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is value investing in simple terms?
Value investing is buying quality companies for less than they're worth, then holding until the market recognizes their true value. It's like buying a $500 item on sale for $300.

What is growth vs. value investing?
Growth investing focuses on companies with rapid revenue/earnings growth (often tech startups). 

Value investing focuses on established companies trading below their intrinsic value (often mature, dividend-paying companies).

How do I know if a stock is undervalued?
Calculate valuation metrics like P/E ratio (ideally 15-30) and P/B ratio (compared to the companies historical P/B averages). 

Look for strong fundamentals: consistent earnings, competitive advantages, and solid management.

What's a value trap?
A value trap is a stock that looks cheap but is actually declining for good reason - falling earnings, no innovation, or losing competitive position. Not every cheap stock is a bargain.

Can value investing still work in 2026?
Yes. While growth stocks dominated the 2010s (tech boom), value investing cycles have historically returned. 

Market cycles ensure both strategies work at different times. Value investing has historically offered consistent returns with lower risk over long periods.

How much money do I need to start value investing?
You can start with any amount. Many brokers offer fractional shares, letting you buy portions of expensive stocks. 

What tools do value investors use?
Financial statement analysis (10-K reports), stock screeners, valuation calculators, and industry research. Free resources include Yahoo Finance, SEC's EDGAR database, and company investor relations pages.